Methodology

How we rank dentists, in plain terms

This page explains how we rank dentists on every Utah city page: paid placements first, always labeled, then everyone else in a fixed, published order.

Tooth model holding a dental mirror and explorer in front of a blurred dental chair

Paid placement is always labeled, so you can see exactly what was bought.

On every city page, paid placements come first. Sponsored listings (Tier 3, at most two per city, pinned in their own city) sit at the top, then Featured (Tier 2), then Basic (Tier 1). Each one is labeled. Best Dentists in Utah sells these spots to practices, and the label is what lets you tell a bought position apart from the rest of the list, so you can weigh it however you like.

Every other practice follows the paid groups. Without Google ratings, a more complete profile (hours, website, specialties, photos) comes first, then the list runs alphabetically. When Google ratings are available, practices inside each group are ordered by a review score instead, and how that score works is explained below. Either way, you can hold any of the Utah city pages up against these rules.

Why not simply sort by stars when ratings are shown? A practice with a single five-star review would land above one where hundreds of patients average 4.9, which says little about either office. Sorting by review count alone has the opposite flaw: the biggest, longest-running offices win whether or not their patients are happy. The review score weighs both, and a plan upgrade does not change it.

Where the listing data comes from

Each listing draws on a small set of sources. When two of them describe the same practice, the records are matched so each practice shows up once.

The federal NPI Registry

The default source is the CMS NPPES registry, the public federal record that gives every U.S. health-care provider a National Provider Identifier. It supplies the practice name, address, phone number and taxonomy code, which is how an orthodontist is told apart from an oral surgeon. It carries no ratings, hours or websites. You can look up any provider yourself in the NPI Registry run by the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services.

The practices themselves

Practices can add or correct their own details, such as hours, specialties, insurance plans, photos and a website, through the listing forms. Every change waits for a person to review it before it appears.

Google ratings

Google star ratings and review counts are optional. They appear only when they are available for a listing, and they are always labeled with their source. We show them as published and never write or edit reviews. When no rating is available, a listing shows no stars or counts at all.

How ratings are weighed when they are shown

When Google ratings are available, practices inside each plan group are ordered by a review score rather than by stars alone. The score looks at both the rating and how many reviews stand behind it.

A practice with only a handful of reviews stays close to the Utah average until more patients weigh in. A practice with hundreds of reviews is judged mostly on its own rating.

Why 4.9 from 300 reviews beats 5.0 from 1

  • Many reviews make a rating more trustworthy
  • A perfect score from one review counts for less
  • Plan tier never changes a practice’s review score

How we rank dentists on a city page, top to bottom

Paid Priority Placement listings sit at the very top of their own city page with a Sponsored badge. A city can have two at most, and the pin applies only in the city it was bought for.

Paid Featured listings come next, each with a Featured badge and an outlined card.

Basic (Tier 1)

Basic is the entry paid plan, adding a logo, photos and a website link. These listings follow Featured and are labeled as paid like the groups above them. Plan details are on the pricing page.

All other practices

Every free and unclaimed practice follows the paid groups. A practice does not have to pay, or even know it is listed, to appear here.

Order inside each group

Without ratings, profiles with more of their hours, website, specialties and photos filled in come first, then alphabetical order. When Google ratings are available, the review score above sets the order instead.

Top-five table, below the listings

Only when ratings are available, a table of the five highest review scores in the city appears below the listings. Plan tier never affects it.

Questions about how we rank dentists

Yes. The paid tiers (Sponsored, Featured and Basic) sit above all other listings on a city page, and they are always labeled. Paying cannot change a practice’s rating or review score, and it has no effect on the top-five reviews table.

Review score and nothing else. The table appears below the listings only when Google ratings are available, shows the five highest review scores in that city, and plan tier has no effect on it. Without ratings, there is no table.

Any ratings showncome from outside sources such as Google, each labeled with its source,, not from reviews collected on this site. When they appear they are labeled with their source, and they are not added to the page code as aggregate-rating markup for search engines.

Listings re-sync from their sources in small batches, monthly by default. A correction sent by a practice goes live when it is approved, and the corrected fields are then protected from being overwritten by later imports.

In its normal plan group, ordered by profile completeness (hours, website, specialties and photos), then alphabetically. No stars or review count are shown, rather than a zero.

Through the claim and update form, with the proposed changes and the sender’s role at the practice. Every submission waits in a review queue, and nothing goes live on the site until a person approves it.

Is your listing wrong?

Send the correct name, address, hours or specialties through the claim form. Each change is checked against the current listing and goes live only once it has been reviewed and approved.